东亚福利体制的理论动态：30年间的国外观察

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 东亚福利体制研究自1986年起至今已经走过了30年的发展历程，它不但对丰富我国社会福利理论具有重要的学术意义，而且已经成为我国借鉴国外先进福利经验的实践捷径。利用相关文献对有关东亚福利体制的外文研究展开详析。东亚福利体制研究的学理脉络稳定且持续，已经成长为福利体制比较研究的核心问题；该议题尽管也存在着广泛的学术讨论，但是存在性议题、典型特征议题和未来趋势议题才是当前最为典型的学术论域。该议题的未来研究应该继续保持适度的学术宽容性，增强统计数据库的收集与运用能力，并需要积极培育和引领中青年学者成长。

关键词: 东亚福利体制, 国外观察, 存在性, 典型特征, 未来趋势

Abstract: Researches on East Asian welfare regime has experienced 30 years development since 1986. It not only largely enriches our social welfare theory but also providesfrom foreign advanced practices significant reference for China. This study wants to complete a deep analysis on foreign researches of East Asian welfare regime through literature-review, and observes that researches on this topic seems to be stable and continuous, which has been one of the most important issues in welfare regime; meanwhile, although widespread debates can be found, theoretical disputes among its existent issue, typical characters and future trends issue has taken up a large degree of differentiation. This study suggests that we should continue to maintain enough academic forbearance, enhance the ability for collecting or using statistical database, and actively cultivate or guide our young scholars.

Key words: East Asian welfare mechanism, overseas studies, existence, typical feature, future trends

中图分类号:

C913.7

万国威, 刘晨, 陈梦真. 东亚福利体制的理论动态：30年间的国外观察[J]. 社会工作与管理, 2018, 18(4): 66-74.

WAN Guowei, LIU Chen, CHEN Mengzhen. Theoretical Trends of East Asian Welfare Regime: Overseas Studies in Recent 30 Years[J]. SOCIAL WORK AND MANAGEMENT, 2018, 18(4): 66-74.

参考文献

[1] MIDGLEY JAMES. Industrialization and welfare:the case of the four little tigers[J]. Social policy & administration, 1986, 20(3):225-238.
[2] CHOW NELSON. Western and Chinese ideas of social welfare[J]. International social work, 1987, 30(1):31-41.
[3] JONES CATHERINE. Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan:Oikonomic Welfare States[J]. Government and opposition, 1990, 25(1):446-462.
[4] TABATA HABOR. The Japanese welfare state:its structure and transformation[J]. Annals of the institute of social science, 1990, 32(1):1-29.
[5] CHUNG DOUGLAS, HAYNES ALPHONSO. Confucian welfare philosophy and social change technology:an integrated approach for international social development[J]. International social work, 1993, 36(1):37-46.
[6] JEFFERY SACHS. Reforms in Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union in light of the eastern asian experience[J]. Journal of Japanese and International Economic, 1995, 9(1):454-485.
[7] RODRIK DANI. Coordination failures and government policy:a model with applications to East Asia and Eastern Europe[J]. Journal of international economics, 1996, 40(2):1-22.
[8] ESPING-ANDERSEN GOSTA. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism[M]. Cambridge:Policy Press, 1990.
[9] KOWN HUCK JU. Beyond European welfare regimes:comparative perspectives on East Asian welfare systems[J]. Journal of social policy, 1997, 26(4):467-484.
[10] KOWN HUCK JU. Eastern Asia Welfare States in transition:challenges and opportunities[J]. IDS bulletin, 1999, 30(4):82-93.
[11] CHAU RUBY, YU SAM. Social welfare and economic development in China and Hong Kong[J]. Critical social policy, 1999, 19(1):87-107.
[12] HOLLIDAY IAN. Productivist Welfare Capitalism:social policy in East Asia[J]. Policy studies, 2000, 48(1):706-723.
[13] ARTS WIL, GELISSEN JOHN. Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism or more? A state-of-the-art report[J]. Journal of European social policy, 2002, 12(2):138-158.
[14] BAMBRA CLARE. Defamilisation and Welfare State Regimes:a cluster analysis[J]. International journal of social welfare, 2007, 16(4):326-338.
[15] WALKER ALAN, WONG CHACK-KIE. The Ethnocentric Construction of the Welfare State[M]//KENNETT P. A handbook of comparative social policy. Cheltenham:Edward Elgar, 2004:50-116.
[16] KU YEUN WEN, JONES FINER CATHERINE. Developments in East Asian welfare studies[J]. Social policy and administration, 2007, 41(2):115-31.
[17] ESPING-ANDERSEN GOSTA. Hybrid or unique? the Japanese Wealfare State between Europe and American[J]. Journal of European social policy, 1997, 7(3):179-189.
[18] 科斯塔·埃斯平-安德森. 转变中的福利国家[M]. 重庆:重庆出版社, 2003.
[19] CHRISTIAN ASPALTER. The East Asian welfare model, international[J]. Journal of social welfare, 2006, 15(1):290-301.
[20] STEPHAN HAGGARD, ROBERT R. Kaufman, development, Democracy and Welfare States[M]//Latin America, East Asia and Eastern Europe. Princeton and Oxford:Princeton University Press, 2008.
[21] KIM PIL HO. The East Asian Welfare State debate and surrogate social policy:an exploratory study on Japan and South Korea[J]. Socio-economic review, 2010, 8(3):411-435.
[22] RUBY CHAU, SAM YU. Defamilisation of twenty-two countries:its implications for the study of East Asian welfare regime[J]. Social policy and society, 2013, 12(3):355-367.
[23] GOODMAN ROGER, WHITE GORDON, KWON HUCK JU. The East Asian welfare model:welfare orientalism and the state[M]. London:Routledge, 1998.
[24] PAUL WILDING. Is the East Asian welfare model still productive?[J]. Journal of Asian public policy, 2008, 1(1):18-31.
[25] AKIRA SUEHIRO. East Asian welfare system:company benefits and social security in seven countries[M]. Kyoto:Minerva Shobo Publication, 2010.
[26] YU WAI KAM. The contributions of the health decommodification typologies to the study of the East Asian welfare regime[J]. Social policy & administration, 2012, 46(1):108-128.
[27] DICKY WAI LEUNG LAI. Macao's welfare model:an extreme world of welfare capitalism?[J]. International social work, 2014, 57(6):676-687.
[28] 김순양. 동아시아의 발전국가와 사회정책[J]. 행정논총, 2015, 53(2):27-68.
[29] CHOI YOUNG JUN, KIM JIN WOOK. Contrasting approaches to old-age income protection in Korea and Taiwan[J]. Aging and society, 2010, 30(7):1135-1152.
[30] KIM SUNG MOON. Confucianism and acceptable inequalities[J]. Philosophy and social Criticism, 2013, 39(10):983-1004.
[31] JOHN HUDSON, STEFAN KÜHNER, NAN YANG. Productive welfare, the East Asian ‘model’ and beyond:placing welfare types in greater China into context[J]. Social policy and society, 2014, 13(2):301-305.
[32] PENG ITO, WONG JOSEPH. Institutions and institutional purpose:continuity and change in East Asian social policy[J]. Politics & society, 2008, 36(1):61-88.
[33] FELTENSTEIN ANDREW, ROCHON CELINE, SHAMLOO MARAL. High growth and low consumption in East Asia:how to improve welfare while avoiding financial failures[J]. Journal of development economics, 2010, 91(1):25-36.
[34] CHUNG YING CHIH, CHUNG KUN YANG, CHEN YOU RONG, et al. Welfare state regimes, infant mortality and life expectancy:integrating evidence from East Asia[J]. Epidemiol community health, 2012, 66(23):1-4.
[35] JOO JAEH YUN. Explaining social policy adoption in South Korea:the cases of the medical insurance law and the minimum wage law[J]. Journal of social policy, 1999, 28(3):387-412.
[36] MARSTON GREG. Welfare reform in East Asia:towards workfare[J]. Asia Pacific journal of social work and development, 2012, 22(1):75-76.
[37] 최병목, 김재열. 삼민주의와 동아시아 복지:사회복지정 변화와 연구동향이 동아시아 3국에 주는 시사점[C]. 한국사회복지정책학회 2012춘계학술대회 발표논문집, 2012.
[38] TAM TONY. Humanitarian attitudes and support of government responsibility for social welfare[J]. International social work, 2003, 46(4):449-467.
[39] LEE YIH JIUNN, KU YEUN WEN. East Asian welfare regimes:testing the hypothesis of the developmental welfare state[J]. Social policy & administration, 2007, 41(2):197-212.
[40] HYE SUK WANG. Familialisation effects of the state welfare:focused on the National Health Insurances in South Korea and Taiwan[J]. International journal of social welfare, 2015, 25(1):29-41.
[41] WILLIAM LI. East Asian welfare model refocus? a case study on economic support for the elderly living alone in Taiwan[J]. International journal of social welfare, 2012, 22(2). 260-268.
[42] RAYMOND CHAN, NAOKO SOMA, JUNKO YAMASHITA. Care regimes and responses:East Asian experiences compared[J]. Journal of comparative social welfare, 2011, 27(2):175-186.
[43] IZUHARA MISA, FORREST RAY. 'Active families':familization, housing and welfare across generations in East Asia[J]. Social policy & administration, 2013, 47(5):520-541.
[44] CHUNG DOUGLAS, HAYNES ALPHONSO. Confucian welfare philosophy and social change technology:an integrated approach for international social development[J]. International social work, 1993, 36(1):37-46.
[45] SHIN CHANG SIK, SHAW IAN. Social policy in South Korea:cultural and structural factors in the emergence of welfare[J]. Social policy & administration, 2003, 37(4):328-341.
[46] SUNG SIRIN. Women reconciling paid and unpaid work in a confucian welfare state:the case of South Korea[J]. Social policy & administration, 2003, 37(4):342-360.
[47] LIN KA. Family policy and social order comparing the dynamics of family policy-making in scandinavia and confucian Asia[J]. International journal of social welfare, 2003, 12(1):2-13.
[48] HORT OLSSEN SVEN, KUHNLE STEIN. The coming of East and South-East Asian welfare states[J]. Journal of European social policy, 2000, 10(2):162-184.
[49] LIN KA, CHAN RAYMOND. Repositioning three models of social policy with reference to East Asian welfare systems[J]. International social work, 2013, 1(1):1-9.
[50] 노경호. 동아시아 복지국가의 발전과 저발전:제도의 행위자, 그리고 사회경제적 변화[J]. 한국정치학회보, 2014, 48(5):207-262.
[51] CROISSANT AUREL. Changing welfare regimes in East and Southeast Asia:crisis, change and challenge[J]. Social policy & administration, 2004, 38(5):504-524.
[52] JAMES MIDGLEY, KWONG-LEUNG TANG. Social policy and poverty in East Asia:the role of social security[M]. London:Routledge, 2010.
[53] RONALD RICHARD, DOLING JOHN. Testing home ownership as the cornerstone of welfare:lessons from East Asia for the West[J]. Housing studies, 2012, 27(7):940-961.
[54] KWON HUCK JU. Transforming the developmental welfare state in East Asia[J]. Development and change, 2005, 36(3):477-497.
[55] TIMOTHY KA-YING WONG, PO-SAN WAN, KENNETH WING-KIN LAW. The public's changing perceptions of the condition of social welfare in Hong Kong:lessons for social development[J]. Social policy & administration, 2010, 44(5). 620-640.
[56] KIM YOUNG HWA. Productive welfare:Korea's third way?[J]. International journal of social welfare, 2003, 12(1). 61-67.
[57] WOOD GEOF, GOUGE IAN. A comparative welfare regime approach to global social policy[J]. World development, 2006, 34(10):1696-1712.
[58] HWANG GYU JIN. Explaining welfare state adaptation in East Asia:the cases of Japan, Korea and Taiwan[J]. Asian journal of social science, 2011, 40(1):174-202.
[59] IAN GOUGH. Globalization and regional welfare regimes:the East Asian case[J]. Global social policy, 2001, 1(2):163-189.
[60] HUANG CHIEN CHUNG, KU YUN WEN. Effectiveness of social welfare programmes in East Asia:a case study of Taiwan[J]. Social policy & administration, 2011, 45(7):733-751.
[61] KWONG-LEUNG TANG. Social welfare development in East Asia[M]. Chippenham:Antony Rowe Ltd, 2000.
[62] PAUL WILDING. Is the East Asian welfare model still productive?[J]. Journal of Asian public policy, 2008, 1(1):18-31.
[63] OCHIAI EMIKO. Leaving the West, rejoining the East? gender and family in Japan's semi-compressed modernity[J]. International sociology, 2014, 29(3):209-228.
[64] CHRISITIAN ASPALTER. Discovering the Welfare State in East Asia[M]. Westport:Praeager, 2002.
[65] KWON HUCK JU. The reform of the developmental Welfare State in East Asia[J]. International Journal of Social Welfare, 2009, 18(1):12-21.
[66] CHAN CHAK KWAN, NGOK KINGLUN. Welfare reform in East Asia:towards workfare[M]. London:Routledge, 2011.
[67] KU YEUN WUN, JONES FINER CATHERINE. Developments in East Asian welfare studies[J]. Social Policy & administration, 2007, 41(2):115-131.

Metrics

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Shared

Discussed